Skip to main content Skip to search
Are We Prisoners of Shangrila? Orientalism, Nationalism, and the Study of Tibet
Journal of the International Association of Tibetan Studies
Format: Journal Article
Publication Year: n.d.
Sources ID: 126592
Visibility: Public (group default)
Abstract: (Show)

This essay examines the consequences of Said's critique of orientalism for Tibetan studies, particularly in relation to Lopez's claim that we are all "prisoners of Shangrila." The paper takes up this critique in relation to Lopez's treatment of the present Dalai Lama, arguing that although his critique is useful, it exaggerates the scope and power of orientalism, and in the process ends up de-historicizing and reifying Tibetan culture into a closed totality that either remains unchanged or becomes debased through the intervention of the West. This, the essay argues, leaves little room for alternatives to orientalism, both in the West and among Tibetans, and thus ends up repeating the exclusionary gesture that this critique had sought to debunk. (Than Garson 2005-09-22)