Skip to main content Skip to search
Beyond cell doctrine: complexity theory informs alternate models of the body for cross-cultural dialogue
Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
Short Title: Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci.Beyond cell doctrine
Format: Journal Article
Publication Date: 2009/08//
Pages: 263 - 269
Sources ID: 95261
Visibility: Public (group default)
Abstract: (Show)
Cell doctrine is the foundational paradigm of Euro-American medicine and biology. Even without stepping outside that tradition, one may imagine alternate models of the body such as a fluid model in which cells do not exist or a model wherein cells are described as overlapping fields of molecular organization in space and time. With a complexity analysis of cell biology, we find that the existence of cells as unitary entities, as things, is contingent on the level of scale at which the body is observed. Therefore, alternate models of the body may be conceived that are specific and appropriate to other levels of scale. These ideas suggest that some bodily phenomena, particularly from Asian traditions, which have previously resisted explanation from within the cell-based Euro-American tradition (e.g., acupuncture) may be productively investigated with one or more of these other models. Additionally, the seemingly metaphorical concepts from Tibetan medicine of the coarse, energy, and subtle bodies may represent precise, though somewhat poetically expressed representations of the body at different levels of scale.